close
close
The Detroit Tigers need to come back with momentum after a long-overdue blow in the ALDS

CLEVELAND – Before the opening game of this ALDS on Saturday, Detroit Tigers manager AJ Hinch predicted that their magic carpet ride would eventually run into a storm cloud.

“At some point,” he said, “someone is going to hit you in the mouth.”

Phew! Those spinning Tigers eyeballs were thanks to the first five Cleveland batters on Saturday, all of whom reached base – the last of them, Lane Thomas, cracking a hanging slider nearly 400 feet into the left field seats for a three-run home run and one Leading 5-0.

If this were a movie scene, they would have shouted “Stop!” If Howard Cosell had called it, it would have been “Down goes Detroit!” If you trail by five runs before recording an out, you can somehow tell it's not your day.

“We never recovered from it,” Hinch would say.

Now it's true, because for a game that's often accused of taking too long to be over within the first few minutes, that's kind of ironic. But this was more than just a big early lead in a baseball playoff. The Tigers faced a division winner who was just waiting to show his skills to the roaring hometown fans after a six-day break. And had his best pitcher, Tanner Bibee, on the mound. Cleveland is a team that wins by holding the runs together, pushing the starters to the sixth inning and then saying goodnight by taking over the best bullpen in baseball.

On Saturday their formula worked perfectly. Detroit starter Tyler Holton (and on this team we use the term “starter”) loosely on a leadoff double, walked the next batter, allowed a run on a hard hopper that bounced off an error by third baseman Zach McKinstry , and then gave up a single .

Hinch waved. Holton's day was over. Two hits. A walk. Two runs allowed. No outs.

As far as ominous signs go, this is a black cat. A cracked mirror. Walking under a ladder.

“They landed a good first punch,” Holton admitted.

Pow.

SHAWN WINDSOR: A missed goal cost the Detroit Tigers Game 1. But they also fought on their own

“Bullpen chaos” beats “pitching chaos”

The Tigers might have survived that two-run deficit. But when Thomas stepped in and rolled out Reese Olson's first pitch, giving him a 5-0 lead, Cleveland's odds of winning rose to 91%, if you like those new-age metrics. Those of us who have simply watched a ton of baseball might think that a Detroit comeback is unlikely.

“I mean, sometimes their guy beats our guy,” Hinch said after the 7-0 loss was over. “Reese was ready. … We really can’t blame anyone for anything other than a good swing on the court that changed the game.”

Olson later said he hung a slider and Thomas jumped on it. For his part, Thomas said he was looking for a fastball. Whatever. Ball hits bat. The ball went over the wall. Three runs in.

To his credit, Olson stayed out there and pitched five complete innings, giving up just two more hits and striking out four.

But if Hinch's mix-and-match starters are referred to as “pitching chaos,” then the Guardians apply “bullpen chaos.” They used four substitutes on Saturday: Cade Smith, Tim Herron, Hunter Gaddis and super-closer Emmanuel Clase. Together they killed seven tigers.

And didn't give a hit.

Pow.

“We are still standing”

Now there are many reasons not to be angry about this defeat. The first is Tarik Skubal, MLB's best pitcher this year, who starts Game 2 for the Tigers on Monday. We won't say he's hard to beat, but it's good that it's not a night game. He usually runs out of light.

The second is that the Tigers expected a game like this. They jumped out to a 10-1 lead to clinch a playoff spot, took a breather in two meaningless games against the White Sox and stormed back to defeat the Astros in a series that was over so quickly that I believe some Houston fans are still arriving at the ballpark.

“You can’t win like that day after day, can you?” I asked Holton.

“I mean, you may” he said, “But it's baseball. It's hard to win every day. …We're still standing. We will defend ourselves.”

Baseball gurus always talk about getting the first batter out. The Tigers failed to do that in the first three innings on Saturday. They have to clean it up on Monday. And their 13 strikeouts in Game 1 can't be a harbinger of this series, otherwise we'll be rooting exclusively for the Lions again this weekend.

In boxing it's called a rematch. In baseball, it's just the next game. Hinch called Thomas' home run “a blow from which we have not recovered.” But this is a young team. Bruises heal quickly.

Or, to twist an old phrase: “Today pow, tomorrow gone.”

Contact Mitch Albom: [email protected]. Check out the latest updates on his charities, books and events at MitchAlbom.com. Follow him @mitchhalbom.

By Vanessa

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *